In the world of coin collecting, some treasures are hiding in plain sight. Among them, the Liberty Head Nickel has become the stuff of legend. While many assume old nickels are only worth face value, a select few Liberty Nickels have stunned collectors by fetching over $10 million — and one of them was shockingly discovered at a local garage sale.
Let’s take a closer look at the top 3 Liberty Nickels that shattered records and turned spare change into multimillion-dollar fortunes.
1. The 1913 Liberty Head Nickel — The $11 Million Rarity
The 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is undoubtedly the most prized coin in this series. Only five examples are known to exist, and their creation is shrouded in mystery. These coins were struck under unusual conditions at the Philadelphia Mint and were never officially released to the public.
Over time, they disappeared into private collections and reappeared decades later, each carrying a fascinating history. The most famous, nicknamed the “Hawaii Five-O” coin due to its appearance on the popular TV show, eventually sold for over $11 million in a private transaction.
Its extremely low production number, mysterious background, and pop culture fame make it one of the most coveted coins in U.S. history.
2. Another 1913 Liberty Nickel — Found at a Garage Sale
This incredible story sounds like a movie plot but is true. In the early 2000s, a family shopping at a neighborhood garage sale bought a box of assorted items that included an old coin they thought might have value.
That coin turned out to be one of the five original 1913 Liberty Nickels. After being authenticated, it was named the “Walton Specimen” and valued at over $10 million. It had been lost for decades following its previous owner’s death in a car accident in the 1960s. The coin sat unnoticed in a box until that lucky day at the garage sale changed everything.
This find stunned the coin collecting world and sparked fresh excitement about rare coins hidden in everyday places.
3. The Eliasberg Specimen — The Only One in Mint State
Of the five known 1913 Liberty Head Nickels, the Eliasberg Specimen is unique due to its near-perfect condition. It is the only example considered to be in mint state, meaning it has been preserved without significant wear over the years.
This coin was part of the famous Louis E. Eliasberg Collection, which is the only complete set of U.S. coins ever assembled. When this particular nickel was sold, it fetched over $10 million, ranking it among the most valuable American coins ever sold.
Collectors prize it not just for its rarity but also for its exceptional condition, which surpasses that of the other known specimens.
Why Liberty Nickels Are So Valuable
Liberty Head Nickels were minted between 1883 and 1913, with millions produced during those years. However, the 1913 issue was never officially released, and its production is believed to be the work of an unauthorized mint employee. This backstory, combined with the extreme rarity of the 1913 coins, makes them highly sought after by collectors worldwide.
The fascinating tales surrounding these coins — including losses, unexpected discoveries, and media appearances — add to their allure and worth.
Could You Be Holding a Fortune?
While finding one of the five known 1913 Liberty Head Nickels is highly unlikely, stories like the garage sale discovery show that rare coins can appear where you least expect them. Old coin jars, estate sales, and inherited collections might hide significant value.
If you come across a Liberty Nickel, especially one dated 1913, it’s wise to have it examined by a professional. Even common dates can sometimes have unique errors or variations that collectors prize.
Final Thoughts
The world of coin collecting is full of surprises, and the Liberty Nickel proves that even the smallest coins can have incredible stories—and huge price tags. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just clearing out old belongings, it’s worth taking a closer look at your spare change.
FAQs
Q1: Why are the 1913 Liberty Head Nickels so rare?
A1: Only five were ever made, and their production was unofficial, making them extremely scarce and valuable.
Q2: How much can a 1913 Liberty Nickel be worth?
A2: These coins can sell for over $10 million, depending on their condition and provenance.
Q3: How can I verify if my Liberty Nickel is genuine?
A3: Have the coin evaluated by a professional numismatist or a reputable coin grading service.
Q4: Are all Liberty Head Nickels valuable?
A4: Most are common and worth only face value or slightly more, but rare years like 1913 are highly valuable.
