Missing 1913 Liberty Nickel Could Be Worth $9.9 Million — Have You Seen It?

In the World of Coin Collecting

Some coins go beyond being just historical items — they become legendary. One of the most famous is the extremely rare 1913 Liberty Head Nickel, a U.S. coin believed to be worth up to $9.9 million. What adds to its mystery? Only five are known to exist, and one is still missing — possibly hidden in an attic, an old box, or even among regular pocket change.

A Coin That Was Never Supposed to Exist

In 1912, the U.S. Mint officially ended the production of Liberty Head nickels and introduced the Buffalo nickel the following year. Yet somehow, five Liberty Head nickels bearing the 1913 date mysteriously appeared — with no records showing they were ever made. Since these coins were never authorized, their existence continues to spark debate and fascination among experts and collectors.

Most experts believe they were quietly struck by someone working at the Mint, either as a test or during an unofficial production. These coins only came to light in the 1920s when coin dealer Samuel W. Brown began showcasing one at conventions, stirring a buzz that hasn’t faded to this day.

Five Were Made, But Only Four Are Accounted For

Of the five known 1913 Liberty Nickels:

• Two are owned privately
• Two are in museum collections
• One remains missing

The whereabouts of the fifth coin remain unknown. It hasn’t been seen in decades. Some think it may have been lost or destroyed, while others believe it could still be hiding in an old coin collection or mislabeled jar — just waiting to be found.

Why Is It Worth So Much?

The value of the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel comes from its extreme rarity. Only five were ever made, and one is still lost. This unique backstory, paired with the coin’s historical significance, makes it incredibly desirable. One known example sold for $3.7 million in 2010. Experts now believe the missing piece could fetch up to $9.9 million or more if found.

Collectors are drawn to the mystery, and that adds to its worth. It’s not just a coin — it’s a symbol of hidden treasure.

Could It Be Sitting in Your Pocket?

As unlikely as it sounds, it’s not impossible. There have been real stories of valuable coins showing up in unexpected places — like a rare penny discovered in a child’s piggy bank, or a high-value coin found in a vending machine.

While finding the 1913 Liberty Nickel is a long shot, it’s stories like this that encourage people to take a closer look at the coins they have tucked away.

A Legend That Refuses to Fade

The missing Liberty Head Nickel remains one of the greatest mysteries in coin collecting. Historians, collectors, and auction houses still hope it will be discovered someday — possibly becoming the most valuable American coin ever sold.

Until that day comes, the legend lives on and continues to inspire treasure hunters and coin enthusiasts around the world.

Final Thought

The missing 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is more than just a coin — it represents a blend of mystery, history, and the thrill of discovery. So next time you stumble across an old coin, take a second look. You might be holding a fortune — or at the very least, a piece of American history.

FAQs